You Can’t Say That!

via Daily Prompt: Stifle



I wonder that we’ve ever really had true free speech. George Orwell’s experience in Spain (1936) was such that he portrayed both left and right as having stifled free speech in his novel, Animal Farm. Every form of totalitarian government has stifled free speech, but in recent times even liberal democracies have resorted to enacting laws that limit free speech.

In an interview in 2012 (The Telelgraph, October 18, 2012), Rowan Atkinson (aka Blackadder, Mr. Bean) tilted at the law in England – The Public Order Act. Atkinson criticised the “Creeping culture of censoriousness” and went on to point out that we have entered a time when it has become dangerous to protest. In other words we are losing our basic rights to speak out. He was not speaking in favour (as some tend to confuse free speech with the right to vilify and slander) of the right to say anything, especialy hate speech, but that we have gone too far, curtailing even basic free speech.

Atkinson claims that in trying to outlaw insult, because insult is difficult to define, we end up prosecuting one the basis of insult, ridicule, sarcasm, criticism, or even stating an alternative view to the status quo (the subversive, Orwell speaks directly to this in his novel 1984). In reality, in stifling free speech we end up with repression.

Many have paid for speaking out, Alexander Solzhenitsyn, who criticised Joseph Stalin, was sent to labour camps by Stalin. Umberto Eco wrote in the ‘Name of the Rose’ (later a movie starring Sean Connery) how the Vatican maintained a list of books to be destroyed, how the church didn’t like criticism of the institution. The leaders of the French Revolution brutally repressed criticism. Hitler, Stalin, Franco, Castro, Pinochet, Mao, Idi Armin, Robert Mugabe, all loathed and tried to regulate criticism. In recent times Donald Trump has complained about free speech (which is ironic). Kim Jong-un carries on a tradition of repressing poitical criticism in North korea.

The English philosopher John Stuart Mill commented (‘On Liberty’ 1859, Penguin, pp 83 -84)  that we should not employ censorship because this would prevent people from making up their own minds (horror of horrors). Interesting thought, Mill clearly wasn’t frightened of public free speech, and he believed free speech wouldn’t cause the collapse of society nor descend to harm or hate. But there are worrying signs that liberal democracies are moving towards control of free speech by creating laws where criticism of government becomes an offence!

No one likes criticism, but surely that is no reason to be petulant and defensive and hide behind laws? Sometimes we need to push back, sometimes others need to push back against us. Criticism can sharpen us,  it can energise us, help us to refine our view, and help us to grow. Let’s not fear each other, but instead let’s embrace the idea that society, and in particular, people’s views, are not homogenous, and we won’t all agree, and we won’t like all that we hear and read about ourselves. Instead, let’s embrace the difference, let’s hold to the value of free speech.



Filed under community, history, life, Philosophy/Theology, politics

18 responses to “You Can’t Say That!

  1. Beautifully crafted and insightful

    Liked by 3 people

  2. Trump complains about free speech and he loves Putin. Unbelievable!

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Life would lack a certain lustre if we all agreed, all of the time!

    Liked by 3 people

  4. It’s so hard to speak out, then later maybe we regret not speaking out. But sometimes it means paying a huge price. Sophie Scholl of The White Rose spoke out against the Nazi’s – and died for it. Now she is remembered as a hero, she and her brother Hans.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Yes, I was so moved by her story, so many, but I’ve had times of regret, not speaking, now I just embarrass myself and go for it. It has been costly personally, but nothing like Scholl and others like her. Grateful for teh reminder, and for you stopping by.


  5. You encourage me to remember to speak out – thank you!

    Liked by 2 people

  6. very well written and I appreciate the sentiments expressed!
    Reminds of the blue eye brown eye theory … if we don’t speak out we are just as guilty of the atrocities perpetrated 🙂 Criticism is healthy, we all need feedback and then discern if there is substance and whether or not we take it on board.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Your post sounds good. Forgive me for wondering if you would support speech contrary to the prevailing view on college campuses, in Silicon Valley, among Hollywood’s power brokers, and the pompous know-it-alls on both coasts?

    G Thompson – Korea War Vet

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.